Confidentiality and Disclosure Questions
NMC CBT confidentiality practice: the duty of confidence, when disclosure is lawful, need-to-know sharing, and worked scenario answers.
Nurses hold a great deal of private information, and patients trust that it stays private. The Code makes confidentiality a professional duty, and the CBT tests whether you understand both the rule and its limits.
The default is simple: patient information is confidential. The harder skill, and the one the exam probes, is knowing the narrow situations where you can share it, and how much.
The three lawful grounds
You can disclose confidential information when one of these applies:
- The patient consents to the sharing.
- The law requires or permits it, such as a court order or a notifiable disease.
- Disclosure is justified in the public interest, to prevent serious harm.
If none of the three applies, the information stays confidential, however reasonable the request feels and whoever is making it. A police officer asking, a colleague curious about a former patient, a relative wanting an update: none of those is a lawful basis on its own.
Need to know
Sharing inside the care team is legitimate, but it is bounded by the need-to-know principle. The team treating the patient gets the information relevant to that care, not the whole record and not idle detail. Discussing a patient with staff who are not involved, or anywhere you can be overheard, is a breach even when you mean well. A surprising number of B1 questions are really about where and to whom you are talking.
The public interest test
The hardest questions describe a patient whose choices put someone else at risk: the driver with uncontrolled epilepsy who will not inform the DVLA, the person who threatens serious violence. Here confidentiality can yield. You try persuasion first, then disclose only to the body that can act, and only what is necessary to prevent the harm. Proportion matters: telling the right authority is defensible, telling an employer or posting publicly is not.
One point catches people out: the duty does not end when a patient dies. Access by relatives runs through specific legal routes, not an automatic right. Next: record keeping. Five confidentiality scenarios first.
Sources & further reading
Frequently asked questions
Can I discuss a patient with colleagues not involved in their care?
A patient tells me they intend to seriously harm someone. What do I do?
Does confidentiality end when a patient dies?
Check your understanding
Quick quiz: Confidentiality and Disclosure Questions
5questions. Click an answer to see the explanation. Your score is saved on this device only.
- 1
In a hospital lift, a colleague asks how the patient in bay 4 is doing. Several visitors are in the lift. What should you do?
- 2
A police officer asks for a patient's home address. There is no court order and the patient has not consented. What is the correct response?
- 3
A patient with epilepsy continues to drive against medical advice and will not tell the DVLA. What can the nurse do after exhausting persuasion?
- 4
You need to refer a patient to the tissue viability team. How much information should you share?
- 5
A relative of a deceased patient asks to see the medical records. What applies?
Keep reading
Consent Questions: Adults, Capacity and Refusal
NMC CBT consent practice: what makes consent valid, a capacitous adult's right to refuse, implied consent, and worked scenario answers.
Mental Capacity Act Scenario Questions
NMC CBT practice on the Mental Capacity Act 2005: the five principles, the two-stage capacity test, best interests, and worked scenario answers.
Safeguarding Children Scenario Questions
NMC CBT safeguarding children practice: recognising abuse, not promising secrecy, referring to social care, and worked scenario answers.