UK Job Offer Playbook · 2026
What should I do if my current employer makes a counter offer?
Why this matters
Counter offers are an emotional inflection point. Your manager pleads, HR pulls out the stops, and the comp jump is real. But the underlying issues that made you start interviewing rarely change. In 12 years I've seen maybe 1 in 5 counter-offer accepters genuinely thrive — most are gone within 18 months but with the worst outcome: they've burned the bridge with the new employer they declined.
Step-by-step playbook
1) Don't decide in the moment — say 'I appreciate this, can I take 24 hours to consider properly?' 2) Ask yourself: would I be staying for the money or for the underlying change? Money alone fades fast. 3) List the real reasons you wanted to leave: manager, scope, growth, culture, work-life. Has the counter offer addressed each? 4) Demand specifics in writing if you're considering it: new role/title, new manager arrangement (if relevant), salary in writing, formal review terms. Vague 'we'll address that' commitments rarely survive 90 days. 5) Consider future positioning — your manager now knows you almost left. Will this be a black mark or a growth opportunity? Depends on culture. 6) If you decide to accept the counter offer: get every change in writing within 48 hours. 7) If you decline the counter: do so kindly and finally — flip-flopping kills your credibility with both employers.
Word-for-word script / template
Decline counter offer template: 'Hi [Manager], I really appreciate the offer to revise my comp and the conversation we had on [date]. It means a lot. After thinking it through carefully, I've decided to stick with my decision to move. While the financial offer is generous, the reasons I've been considering this change — [scope/growth/specific issue] — aren't fully addressed by it. I want to give the strongest possible handover and ensure a smooth transition over my notice period. I'm committed to making my exit as positive as possible. Thank you, [Your name]'
What NOT to do
Don't: accept the counter in the heat of the moment; let your manager guilt-trip you about loyalty; assume the counter offer guarantees future growth; accept verbal-only promises; flip back and forth between employers; let the new employer wait while you decide (you'll lose them).
Worked example
James handed in his notice for a £85k role. His current manager came back with £80k (up from £68k) and a 'discussion about growth'. He took 24 hours, listed his real reasons (scope, manager autonomy, technology), and realised only the money was changing. He politely declined the counter offer and joined the new employer. 18 months later he'd been promoted twice; his old manager had left the company; the people who took counter offers in his old team had all moved on.
Recruiter pro tip
The single best question to ask yourself: 'Why did this comp lift only appear when I threatened to leave?' If your employer valued you at £80k all along, why were they paying you £68k? The answer is they only pay what they're forced to pay. The relationship has changed permanently — you're no longer a loyal employee, you're a cost minimisation exercise. Most counter offers are reactive panic, not strategic value recognition.
Related playbooks
How do I decline a UK job offer politely?
Decline by phone or email within 48 hours of decision, thanking them specifically for time invested, giving a …
How do I formally accept a UK job offer?
Accept in writing only after you have the full offer letter (base, bonus, pension, holiday, start date, notice…
How do I negotiate a UK job offer?
Always negotiate — every UK employer expects it and almost all have headroom (typically 5-15% on base, plus be…
Related across UK Rights & Guides